The Lying Game (2011)

The Lying Game

Emma, a kind-hearted foster kid who can't catch a break, finds out she has an identical twin sister, Sutton, who - unlike Emma - was adopted by wealthy parents and is seemingly living an ideal life. After their initial meeting, Sutton talks Emma into stepping into her life for a few days while she pursues a lead on their birth mother. Initially excited to do this favor for her sister, Emma soon learns that Sutton has gone missing and could be in trouble. Now, Emma must decide whether to come clean to Sutton's family and risk her own safety in the hope of uncovering her twin sister's true whereabouts, along with the truth about why they were separated in the first place.

The Lying Game

Watch Providers

Tubi TV

Casting arrow_drop_down

Alexandra Chando
Alexandra Chando
as Emma Becker / Sutton Mercer
Alice Greczyn
Alice Greczyn
as Madeline Rybak
Helen Slater
Helen Slater
as Kristin Mercer
Blair Redford
Blair Redford
as Ethan Whitehorse
Andy Buckley
Andy Buckley
as Dr. Ted Mercer
Allie Gonino
Allie Gonino
as Laurel Mercer
Adrian Pasdar
Adrian Pasdar
as Alec Rybak
Christian Alexander
Christian Alexander
as Thayer Rybak
Tyler Christopher
Tyler Christopher
as Dan Whitehorse
Kirsten Zien
Kirsten Zien
as Charlotte Chamberlin
Sharon Pierre-Louis
Sharon Pierre-Louis
as Nisha Randall
Charisma Carpenter
Charisma Carpenter
as Ann Rebecca Sewell
Randy Wayne
Randy Wayne
as Justin Miller
Chris M. Keegan
Chris M. Keegan
as Keegan
Ben Elliott
Ben Elliott
as Derek Rogers
Yara Martinez
Yara Martinez
as Theresa Lopez
Ryan Rottman
Ryan Rottman
as Jordan Lyle
Adam Brooks
Adam Brooks
as Baz
Craig Nigh
Craig Nigh
as Officer Harry
Misha Crosby
Misha Crosby
as Ryan Harwell
Rick Malambri
Rick Malambri
as Eduardo Diaz
Sydney Barrosse
Sydney Barrosse
as Phyllis Chamberlin
Stacy Edwards
Stacy Edwards
as Annie Hobbs
Jennifer Griffin
Jennifer Griffin
as Dr. Hughes
Kenneth Miller
Kenneth Miller
as Travis Boyle
Katherine Willis
Katherine Willis
as Nancy Rogers
Gil Birmingham
Gil Birmingham
as Ben Whitehorse
Dora Madison
Dora Madison
as Lexi Samuel
Peter Malof
Peter Malof
as Mr. Beattie
Debrianna Mansini
Debrianna Mansini
as Clarice Boyle as Clarice
John Scott Horton
John Scott Horton
as Troy
Kathryn Smith-McGlynn
Kathryn Smith-McGlynn
as Dr. Eileen Sandy
Anne Lockhart
Anne Lockhart
as Audrey Sudano
Mitch Ryan
Mitch Ryan
as Luke Coburn
Vivian Nesbitt
Vivian Nesbitt
as Coach Lee
Todd A. Everett
Todd A. Everett
as DJ Randall
Deke Anderson
Deke Anderson
as Randall Webster
Hadley Eure
Hadley Eure
as Alicia Diaz
Wilbur Penn
Wilbur Penn
as Principal Fleming
Brently Heilbron
Brently Heilbron
as Dave
Jack O'Donnell
Jack O'Donnell
as Tom List
Travis Caldwell
Travis Caldwell
as Kelvin
Farah White
Farah White
as Danni Samuels
Chad Halbrook
Chad Halbrook
as Terry
Amelia Jeffries
Amelia Jeffries
as Cindy
Drew Waters
Drew Waters
as Randy Taylor
Monica Peña
Monica Peña
as Coach
Blake Newcomb
Blake Newcomb
as Arianna
Maritza Guerrero
Maritza Guerrero
as Mrs. Ihrig
David Karave
David Karave
as Agent Carter
Lawrence Varnado
Lawrence Varnado
as Detective Larkin
Titos Menchaca
Titos Menchaca
as Tribal Cop
Nellie Gonzalez
Nellie Gonzalez
as Angie
Britt West
Britt West
as Ray Morgan
Daniel Ross Owens
Daniel Ross Owens
as Jesse Brogan
David Born
David Born
as Brody
Amparo García
Amparo García
as Carmella
Gerardo Davila
Gerardo Davila
as Judge Jerry Wyman
Pam Dougherty
Pam Dougherty
as Judge Martha J. Cotter
Nikki Dixon
Nikki Dixon
as Jessica Whitman
Kasey Stevens
Kasey Stevens
as Alyssa
Steve Shearer
Steve Shearer
as Dr. Benson
Tam Jackson
Tam Jackson
as Detective Jackson
Bob Hess
Bob Hess
as Alec's Laywer
arrow_drop_up

Seasons

Season 1

Season 1

Season 2

Season 2

Episodes season 1

  • 1x1

    Pilot

  • 1x2

    Being sutton

  • 1x3

    Double dibs

  • 1x4

    Twinsense and sensibility

  • 1x5

    Over exposed

  • 1x6

    Bad boys break hearts

  • 1x7

    Escape from sutton island

  • 1x8

    Never have i ever

  • 1x9

    Sex, lies and hard knocks high

  • 1x10

    East of emma

  • 1x11

    O twin, where art thou

  • 1x12

    When we dead awaken

  • 1x13

    Pleased to meet me

  • 1x14

    Black and white and green all over

  • 1x15

    Dead man talking

  • 1x16

    Reservation for two

  • 1x17

    No country for young love

  • 1x18

    Not guilty as charged

  • 1x19

    Weekend of living dangerously

  • 1x20

    Unholy matrimony

Episodes season 2

  • 2x1

    The revengers

  • 2x2

    Cheat, play, love

  • 2x3

    Advantage sutton

  • 2x4

    A kiss before lying

  • 2x5

    Much ado about everything

  • 2x6

    Catch her in the lie

  • 2x7

    Regrets only

  • 2x8

    Bride and go seek

  • 2x9

    The grave truth

  • 2x10

    To lie for

NextFilm 2025