Overcompensating (2025)

College. Come as you aren't.

Closeted former football player and homecoming king Benny becomes fast friends with Carmen, a high school outsider on a mission to fit in at all costs. With guidance from Benny's older sister and her campus-legend boyfriend, Benny and Carmen juggle horrible hookups, flavored vodka, and fake IDs.

Overcompensating

Watch Providers

Amazon Prime Video Free with Ads

Casting arrow_drop_down

Benito Skinner
Benito Skinner
as Benny Scanlon
Wally Baram
Wally Baram
as Carmen Neil
Mary Beth Barone
Mary Beth Barone
as Grace Scanlon
Adam DiMarco
Adam DiMarco
as Peter Whitney
Rish Shah
Rish Shah
as Miles Hari
Corteon Moore
Corteon Moore
as Gabe
Holmes
Holmes
as Hailee Matthews
Owen Thiele
Owen Thiele
as George
Nell Verlaque
Nell Verlaque
as Emily
Elias Azimi
Elias Azimi
as Chris
Tomaso Sanelli
Tomaso Sanelli
as Trent
Austin Lindsay
Austin Lindsay
as Trey
Alexandra Beaton
Alexandra Beaton
as Bridget
Lukas Gage
Lukas Gage
as Sammy
Julia Shiplett
Julia Shiplett
as Mimi
Luke Avoledo
Luke Avoledo
as Grayson
Chiara Diberto
Chiara Diberto
as Zoey
Charlie Larsen
Charlie Larsen
as Dean
David Klein
David Klein
as Adam
Megan Fox
Megan Fox
as Megan Fox Poster
Kaia Gerber
Kaia Gerber
as Esther
Matt Rogers
Matt Rogers
as Jered
Ethan Akler
Ethan Akler
as Acapella Member #3
Akosua Amo-Adem
Akosua Amo-Adem
as Professor McClellan
Merrill D'Souza
Merrill D'Souza
as Acapella Member #5
Brais Meis
Brais Meis
as Acapella Member #2
Hesus Ranjo
Hesus Ranjo
as Acapella Member #6
Katharine Reyes
Katharine Reyes
as Acapella Member #4
Mia Stewart-Chamberlain
Mia Stewart-Chamberlain
as Acapella Member #1
Robbie G.K.
Robbie G.K.
as Riley
Natasha Advani Thangkhiew
Natasha Advani Thangkhiew
as Neck Brace Girl
Cooper Levy
Cooper Levy
as Mitch
Abby Garrett
Abby Garrett
as Meg
Connie Britton
Connie Britton
as Kathryn Scanlon
Tommy Do
Tommy Do
as Kevin
Kyle MacLachlan
Kyle MacLachlan
as John Scanlon
Didi Conn
Didi Conn
as Janet
James Van Der Beek
James Van Der Beek
as Charlie
Bowen Yang
Bowen Yang
as Davis
Austin Kurtis
Austin Kurtis
as Young Benny
C.J. Byrd-Vassell
C.J. Byrd-Vassell
as Film Student #3
Declan Cooper
Declan Cooper
as Film Student #2
Liam Marshall
Liam Marshall
as Film Student #4
Guifre Bantjes-Rafols
Guifre Bantjes-Rafols
as Film Student #1
Chanelle Hunter
Chanelle Hunter
as Painter
Xander Hassan
Xander Hassan
as Brock
Connor Price
Connor Price
as Nick
John Ralston
John Ralston
as Professor Cleary
Eston Stiller
Eston Stiller
as Chris's Sidekick
Peter Sarty
Peter Sarty
as Lax Bro
Carolyn Scott
Carolyn Scott
as Carol
Claire Qute
Claire Qute
as Sloan
Cameron Norris
Cameron Norris
as Terry6969
Charli xcx
Charli xcx
as Charli xcx
Maddie Phillips
Maddie Phillips
as Gigi
Rachel Matthews
Rachel Matthews
as
Caleb Hearon
Caleb Hearon
as CJ
Andrea Martin
Andrea Martin
as Dean Jessica Ballick
David Chinchilla
David Chinchilla
as
Emily Corcoran
Emily Corcoran
as Girl at Party #2
Adam Chuckryk
Adam Chuckryk
as Guy in Bathroom
Silas Lam
Silas Lam
as Boy #2
Markus McNamara
Markus McNamara
as Boy #1
Richard Montgomery
Richard Montgomery
as Lap Dance Guy
Rian Michelsen
Rian Michelsen
as Tim
Ty Pravong
Ty Pravong
as
Yasmine Sahid
Yasmine Sahid
as Courtney
Beatrice Schneider
Beatrice Schneider
as Danni
Andreas Tsogkas
Andreas Tsogkas
as Keg Guy
Serena Thompson
Serena Thompson
as Girl at Party #1
Jadon Watson
Jadon Watson
as Vodka Guy
Brennan Clost
Brennan Clost
as Chase
Jonathan Martin
Jonathan Martin
as Bouncer
Darren Marsman
Darren Marsman
as Uber Driver
Violet Grace
Violet Grace
as Unassuming Girl
Mio Adilman
Mio Adilman
as Jeoff
Nadia Aleexev
Nadia Aleexev
as Drunk Tailgate Girl
Boman Martinez-Reid
Boman Martinez-Reid
as Paulie
Don Gough
Don Gough
as EMT #1
Kaanchana Kerr
Kaanchana Kerr
as Painter
Keegan Long
Keegan Long
as Male F&G Recruit #3
Ryan Mhlanga-Martin
Ryan Mhlanga-Martin
as Male F&G Recruit #4
Samuel G. Davey
Samuel G. Davey
as Male F&G Recruit #1
Jayden Wisniewski
Jayden Wisniewski
as Male F&G Recruit #5
Katie Ortencio
Katie Ortencio
as Sharpie Recruit
Joshua Paroyan
Joshua Paroyan
as Male F&G Recruit #6
Ang Kiriakos
Ang Kiriakos
as Female F&G Recruit #1
O'Shani Cardwell
O'Shani Cardwell
as F&G Recruit #3
Hana Stiles
Hana Stiles
as Hana Stiles
Matthew Hill
Matthew Hill
as Male F&G Recruit #2
Ryan Clarke
Ryan Clarke
as F&G Recruit
Julia Gomes
Julia Gomes
as
Jonathon LeRose
Jonathon LeRose
as Brandon
Desiree Akhavan
Desiree Akhavan
as Ronnie
Gabriel Hudson
Gabriel Hudson
as Costume Guy #1
AJ Risi
AJ Risi
as
Kevin Caudle
Kevin Caudle
as
Devonyae Mitchell
Devonyae Mitchell
as Retirement Home Student
Jenny Brizard
Jenny Brizard
as Nurse
Martha Girvin
Martha Girvin
as Doctor
Tony Babcock
Tony Babcock
as Karaoke MC
Daniel Sunga
Daniel Sunga
as Connor
Ava McGregor
Ava McGregor
as Girl 1
Jamie Champagne
Jamie Champagne
as Jeff
Brittany Rae Robinson
Brittany Rae Robinson
as Bartender
Tyler Pearse
Tyler Pearse
as
John Daniel
John Daniel
as Brendan
Victoria Tomazelli
Victoria Tomazelli
as Girl 2
Dan Reilly
Dan Reilly
as Red Face Turd
Belle Lemieux-Chan
Belle Lemieux-Chan
as Pre-Med Student
Maynuka Sarwar
Maynuka Sarwar
as Psych Major
Sarah Bennett
Sarah Bennett
as Rich Girl
Lisa Malanie Pryce
Lisa Malanie Pryce
as Art Major
arrow_drop_up

Seasons

Season 1

Season 1

Episodes season 1

  • 1x1

    Lucky

  • 1x2

    Who's that girl

  • 1x3

    Black and yellow

  • 1x4

    Boom clap

  • 1x5

    Scary monsters and nice sprites

  • 1x6

    The edge of glory

  • 1x7

    Welcome to the black parade

  • 1x8

    Crown on the ground

Recomendation Series

  • Blue Mountain State
  • Love, Victor
  • grown-ish
  • A Different World
  • Chad Powers
  • The Game
  • Undeclared
  • Never Have I Ever
  • Looking
  • Living Single
  • Mid-Century Modern
  • Boots
  • Community
  • Adults
  • Ridiculousness
  • Young Rock
  • The Completely Made-Up Adventures of Dick Turpin
  • Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt
  • PEN15
  • XO, Kitty

NextFilm 2026